Little Pie Company
Little Pie Company
424 W. 43rd St. (btwn 9th and 10th Aves.)
(212) 736-4780
407 W. 14th St. (btwn 9th and 10th Aves.)
(212) 414-2324
Grand Central Terminal ShopLower Dining Course
(212) 983-3538
Little Pie Company knows what they are doing when it comes to pies. I usually visit the midtown location and have tried a lot of their delicious creations! Here is the list of their pies I love: Southern Pecan, Banana Cream, Mississippi Mud, and Sour Cream Apple Walnut….
Southern Pecan
Traditionally made, the filling is in equal quantity to the actual pecans so neither is too overwhelming. I actually wasn’t a fan of pecan pie until I tasted this one.
Banana Cream
So light and fluffy, you can definitely eat an entire small one (they come in small, medium and large)! The crust is so tender, it mixes in your mouth to make it taste like you’re eating banana pudding. It is definitely a pretty presentation with a big puff of whipped cream on top. So delicious!
Mississippi Mud
This is my favorite of all! It literally looks like a big chunk of mashed fudge in a pie pan! It’s actually made of brownie streusel mixed with chocolate in a chocolate cookie crust. This rich goodness is for chocoholics! Once you take a bite, you can’t stop! Seriously, I could not stop eating it! Mmmmm!
Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie
Of course, everyone loves “grandma’s” apple pie, but there is something unique about Little Pie’s version. It is simple with a twist. It is made with hand sliced Granny Smith Apples and fresh sour cream. There is a top layer, the best part, of brown sugar, cinnamon, and walnut streusel. It is absolutely incredible and surprisingly soft and fresh instead of crunchy and hard. Vanilla ice cream is always a good addition, and they serve it!
Lastly, I cannot forget to mention that they make a great carrot cake. Their carrot cake is moist with a crunch from nuts inside. The cream cheese icing is thick and creamy yet a bit crusty. This compliments the consistency of the cake perfectly.
See more of